'Will the PM side with parents or tech bros?': Labour peer demands action on children's smartphone safety

Sir Keir Starmer needs to choose between parents who want stronger action to tackle harmful content on children's phones, or the "tech bros" who are resisting changes to their platforms, Baroness Harriet Harman has said.

Speaking to Beth Rigby on Sky News' Electoral Dysfunction podcast, the Labour peer noted that the prime minister met with the creators of hit Netflix drama Adolescence to discuss safety on social media, but she questioned if he is going to take action to "stop the tech companies allowing this sort of stuff" on their platforms where children can access it.

Sir Keir hosted a roundtable on Monday with Adolescence co-writer Jack Thorne and producer Jo Johnson to discuss issues raised in the series, which centres on a 13-year-old boy arrested for the murder of a young girl, and the rise of incel culture.

Politics latest: Could the UK retaliate against Trump?

The aim was to discuss how to prevent young boys being dragged into a "whirlpool of hatred and misogyny", and the prime minister said the four-part series raises questions about how to keep young people safe from technology.

Sir Keir has backed calls for the four-part drama to be shown in all schools across the country, but Baroness Harman questioned what is going to be achieved by having young people simply watch the show.

"Two questions were raised [for me]," she said. " Firstly - after they've watched it, what is going to be the discussion afterwards?

"And secondly, is he going to act to stop the tech companies allowing this sort of stuff to go online into smartphones without protection of children?

"Because if the tech companies wanted to do this, they could actually protect children. They can do everything they want with their tech."

She acknowledged there are "very big public policy challenges" in this area, but added of the prime minister: "Is he going to side with parents who are terrified and want this content off their children's phones, or is he going to accept the tech bros' resistance to having to make changes?"

? Click here to listen to Electoral Dysfunction on your podcast app ?

Can parliament keep up?

The Labour peer backed the Conservative Party's call for a ban on smartphones in schools to be mandated from Westminster, saying it would "enable all schools not to have a discussion with their parents or to battle it out, but just to say, this is the ruling" from central government, which Ofsted would then enforce.

"I'm sensitive to the idea that we shouldn't constantly be telling schools what to do," she continued. "And they've got a lot of common sense and a lot of professional experience, and they should have as much autonomy as possible.

"But perhaps it's easier for them if it's done top down."

Baroness Harman also questioned the speed with which parliament is actually able to legislate to deal with the very rapid development of new technologies, and posits that it could "change its processes to be able to legislate in real time".

She suggested that a "powerful select committee" of MPs could be established to do that, because "otherwise we talk about it, and then we're not able to legislate for 10 years - by which time that problem has really set in, and we've got a whole load more problems".

On the podcast, the trio also discussed the 10% tariffs imposed on the UK by Donald Trump and the government's efforts to strike a trade deal with the US to mitigate the impact of the levy.

The government has refused to rule out scrapping the Digital Services Tax, a 2% levy on tech giants' revenues in the UK, as part of the negotiations with the Trump administration - a move Baroness Harman said would be "very heartbreaking".

? Click here to listen to Electoral Dysfunction on your podcast app ?

(c) Sky News 2025: 'Will the PM side with parents or tech bros?': Labour peer demands action on children's s