Plans to build a roof terrace and extend an internal mezzanine at Abbey Wharf in Whitby have been rejected by Scarborough Borough Council.
An application seeking to construct a roof terrace with a balcony and to extend the existing second-floor level mezzanine within Abbey Wharf has been refused by the council due to concerns about over-development, amenity, and preservation of the original building.
The scheme proposed multiple changes to the Grade-II listed site at the Market Hall in Whitby, which is made up of an original 19th-century building and a 1960s two-storey extension
The building is currently in a “poor state of structural repair” with one report stating that the building requires propping at the first-floor level as “a matter of urgency”.
The proposal sought to increase the capacity of the existing bar and restaurant to more than 70 covers by extending the second-floor mezzanine level into the adjoining extension to form a part-covered and part-open roof terrace.
According to the applicant, the works would have had “no detriment to the roof and roofscape, whilst also rectifying the structural issues”.
However, Scarborough Council said the plan would “adversely impact upon the appearance of the listed building” and the Whitby conservation area.
A report by the council states:
“The main concern in relation to amenity is the impact of the open roof terrace and additional capacity with 78+ covers to what is already a relatively large establishment within this part of Whitby.”
The planning authority noted that while the scheme proposed to “enliven this part of the harbour and extend a public meeting place” as well as improve a “structurally unsound building” it could not approve the changes.
In rejecting the scheme, the planning authority said:
“It is not considered that the limited public benefit accrued from the extension to the existing business and formation of an open roof terrace outweighs the significant harm to the designated heritage asset.
“There are no exceptional circumstances identified by the authority that would justify such harm.”
It also stated that noise and disturbance “likely to arise from such a development would” result in an adverse impact on surrounding amenity.
The plan was rejected on Wednesday, February 15.
Whitby Couple Take On Epic Challenge In Hope Their Daughter 'Won't Go Blind'
Calls for "Consultative Pause" as Bridlington Care Unit Faces June Closure
Iran Conflict Prompts North Yorkshire Council to Propose Taxi Fare Increase
Wilsons Food Hall Near Scarborough Wins Top Regional Start-Up Award
Heroes Of Withernsea Sea Tragedy And Bridlington Community Champions Honoured At East Riding Awards
Mayor Declares Proposed Tourist Tax A 'Total Game-Changer' For North Yorkshire
Bridlington Town Announces Retained List
Luke Campbell Reflects on His First Year as Mayor of Hull and East Yorkshire
Family Transform Remote North Yorkshire Station Into The Perfect Home
Filey Residents Launch Bold Bid to Save Historic Queen Street Land from Private Development
North Yorkshire Set for Global Spotlight as Council Backs Return of Elite Cycling
Parents Demand Answers Over Whitby School Education Concerns
Comments
Add a comment