North Yorkshire Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner Candidates Talk About Speeding

Candidates vying to become North Yorkshire’s next Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner give their views on how to tackle speeding on the county's roads.

Commissioner candidates vying to become North Yorkshire’s next Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner say they would launch a hard-hitting educational campaign, pressure for more 20mph limits and even consider drafting in firefighters to help tackle residents’ number one concern – speeding.

Ahead of the residents of York and North Yorkshire going to the polls on Thursday to decide who gets the £74,00-a-year role, the five candidates wanting to succeed Philip Allott, who resigned last month amid controversy, have spoken of their determination to get to grips with road safety enforcement and education.

During his time in the role Mr Allott enlisted academics to help redesign efforts to tackle speeding across North Yorkshire to enable North Yorkshire Police to deal with safety on more than 6,000 miles of roads and in 800 villages to cover, saying demand for enforcement was outstripping police resources.

Most of the 72 county councillors agree speeding, and in particular through villages, is the most common issue that residents raise with them.

While fixed speed cameras have repeatedly been deemed an unsuitable solution for the largely rural county, the force has insisted its 12 mobile speed camera vans are used to deter speeding at sites of accidents.

The county’s first commission Julia Mulligan frequently defended the use of the vans and denied they were being used as a revenue generator, despite many residents, councillors and even former police traffic officers believing the contrary due to where they have been sited.

Independent candidate Keith Tordoff said enforcement was not the only answer to tackling speeding and that he would development new ways of dealing with road safety, involving interaction from other agencies such as North Yorkshire County Council. He said he would examine whether the Fire & Rescue Service could help.

He added as a supporter of the 20’s Plenty scheme, but was only in favour of reducing speed limits on roads near schools, high streets and where the community overwhelmingly wants to.

Labour candidate Emma Scott-Spivey said she was backing 20’s Plenty as “road safety is a huge issue across North Yorkshire – not just in built up areas but on our country lanes and major highways”.

She said:

“Some argue that spending money on reducing speeds and improving road safety should not be an expense of fighting ‘real crime’. I don’t agree at all. We must do everything we can to reduce speeds, reduce accidents and reduce fatalities. Police officers and firefighters agree those are very real.”

Stopping short of expressly backing 20s Plenty,  James Barker, of the Liberal Democrats, highlighted how lower traffic volumes during lockdowns led to some shocking levels of speeding, particularly on 30mph roads.

He said:

“If elected I will oversee a review of the police’s approach to enforcing speed limits, including how mobile speed cameras are deployed and revisiting the issue of fixed speed cameras. I will also explore ways to increase collaboration with local authorities and communities to promote community safety.”

Zoe Metcalfe, who is hoping to become the third Conservative in succession to land the role, said education and more publicity were needed as part of the speeding management strategy.

She said:

“I would like to see an emphasis placed on showing drivers the impacts of their speeding from being an anti-social behaviour, a serious and dangerous activity and how their own lives can be impacted if caught breaking the law.”

Women’s Equality Party candidate Hannah Barham-Brown, said as a wheelchair user, speeding was a major concern for her.

She added:

“Although reducing speed limits is outside of my remit as Police, Fire and Crime Commissioner I will work with local councils and residents to advocate for road safety and to ensure that residents’ concerns are being heard.”

The announcement of the election results will take place on 26 November – the day after voters go to the polls.

The candidates standing in the election are:

• Hannah Barham-Brown - Women's Equality Party       
• James Barker - Liberal Democrats
• Zoe Metcalfe - Conservative Party
• Emma Scott-Spivey - Labour Party
• Keith Tordoff - Independent

Information about the candidates can be found at www.choosemypcc.org.uk/area/north-yorkshire

The supplementary vote system will be used for the election. This means people vote for their first and second choice candidates on their ballot paper.

Details of how the supplementary vote system will work at the election count can be found at

https://www.selby.gov.uk/sites/default/files/Documents/Explanation%20on%20Supplementary%20Voting%20for%20PFCC.pdf

There will be additional provisions at polling stations on the day of the election in order to make them Covid secure for voters and staff.